Flow Dynamics above Tidal Bedforms: Characterisation of flow and turbulence over asymmetric tidal dunes under reversing currents
Date Issued
2026-06-12
Author(s)
Supervisors
Referees
Baar, Anne
Abstract
Bedforms are manifestations of the complex interaction between hydrodynamics, sediment transport and morphodynamics in marine and shallow water environments. An understanding of the flow dynamics above bedforms is crucial for the determination of flow patterns, hydraulic roughness, turbulent mixing, macroturbulent structures, sediment entrainment and deposition, and morphodynamic changes. These basic physical processes have direct implications to many practical applications such as waterway management, subsea cable burial and offshore construction safety. Most dune-flow related studies have dealt with angle-of-repose and high-angle dunes which have a lee side > 17° made of a simple straight segment. Recent studies have determined that natural dunes, especially those found in tidal environments, rarely possess high-angle slopes and are mostly asymmetric low-angle dunes with irregularly-shaped lee side. Moreover, the influence of the bidirectionality of flow over dunes caused by the reversing nature of tidal flows is not fully elucidated. The aim of this thesis, therefore, is to provide a detailed understanding of the flow and turbulence dynamics over tidal dunes under reversing currents. Specifically, this thesis investigates how lee side morphology and flow bidirectionality control time-averaged flow (flow separation and turbulent wake), as well as turbulence structures (turbulent events and large-scale coherent flow structures) above intermediate and low-angle tidal dunes. To accomplish this, two sets of flume experiments have been conducted at different scales using for one set an Acoustic Doppler Velocimetry (ADV) and for the other Particle Image Velocimetry (PIV) for velocity measurements. The influence of scale effects on flow properties is also examined by taking advantage of the different geometric scales. The flume experiments are complemented by Reynolds-Averaged Navier-Stokes (RANS)-based numerical modelling.
Flume experiments reveal that both permanent and intermittent flow separation occur over the intermediate-angle dune (mean lee slope = 12°, steep face = 22°) when the flow aligns with the dune asymmetry. A turbulent wake is also observed close to the bed, expanding downstream. On the low-angle dune (mean lee slope = 10°, steep face = 15°), permanent and intermittent flow separations are smaller and no distinct wake forms. Both dunes show shorter separation and wake lengths than high-angle dunes. Under reverse flow, when the flow goes from the steep stoss side over the gentle lee side (mean lee slope = 4°), no permanent separation or coherent wake is observed. Turbulence is weak and diffuse, resembling flat-bed flow. However, when a short steep segment (steep face = 10°) is present on the otherwise gentle slope, an intermittent separation emerges. This shows that even low-angle dunes can generate flow separation if a steep section is present.
The formation and dynamics of large-scale coherent flow structures (CFS) over asymmetric tidal dunes are explored through the instantaneous velocity fields provided by the PIV measurements. Definite large-scale CFS similar to that over high-angle dunes are observed to form and evolve over the intermediate-angle tidal dune when the flow is aligned with the dune symmetry and the lee side is steep. However, weak CFS are observed over the low-angle tidal dune. Under reverse flow conditions, when the flow is opposed to the dune symmetry and the lee sides are gentle, large-scale CFS generation are significantly weakened due to attenuated shear layer development. The observed large-scale CFS characteristics highlight the significant influence of lee side morphology and flow bidirectionality on macroturbulent formation.
Scale effects arise in physical models when all the relevant forces are not perfectly maintained between different geometrically scaled models. The scale series diagnosis (different scales of laboratory dunes in this study) reveals that the main source of scale effects between the experiments is likely to come from the differences in the dune surface roughnesses and, hence, the near-bed flow regime. This mismatch is manifested as differences in the flow and turbulence properties leading to discrepancies in the measured flow properties over dunes. A careful assessment of potential scale effects in experimental models is, therefore, necessary before translating laboratory findings to full field scale conditions.
The complementary numerical experiments using a non-hydrostatic RANS-based model with k-ε turbulence model demonstrate the applicability of the model to predict mean flow and turbulence properties over tidal dunes under reversing currents at both experimental and full field scale conditions. The model reproduces the overall patterns of time-averaged streamwise flow field as well as the turbulent kinetic energy field, an indication of the model capability to capture the primary influence of tidal dune morphology and flow bidirectionality on flow dynamics.
This thesis provides new insights on the characteristics of flow dynamics over tidal dunes through detailed descriptions of flow and turbulence properties provided by multi-scale experimental and numerical modelling approaches. The presence and extent of intermittent and permanent flow separation over tidal dunes, documented for the first time at such a scale, has implications for flow patterns, hydraulic roughness and turbulence generation over tidal dunes. The presence and dynamics of instantaneous, unsteady large-scale CFS observed in this study has far-reaching impact on turbulent mixing and suspended sediment transport over natural tidal dunes. Overall, this thesis provides a first-order hydrodynamic (flow and turbulence) descriptions that can be used as a starting point for further studies involving flow resistance, sediment transport and morphodynamic evolution over natural tidal dunes under reversing tidal flows.
Flume experiments reveal that both permanent and intermittent flow separation occur over the intermediate-angle dune (mean lee slope = 12°, steep face = 22°) when the flow aligns with the dune asymmetry. A turbulent wake is also observed close to the bed, expanding downstream. On the low-angle dune (mean lee slope = 10°, steep face = 15°), permanent and intermittent flow separations are smaller and no distinct wake forms. Both dunes show shorter separation and wake lengths than high-angle dunes. Under reverse flow, when the flow goes from the steep stoss side over the gentle lee side (mean lee slope = 4°), no permanent separation or coherent wake is observed. Turbulence is weak and diffuse, resembling flat-bed flow. However, when a short steep segment (steep face = 10°) is present on the otherwise gentle slope, an intermittent separation emerges. This shows that even low-angle dunes can generate flow separation if a steep section is present.
The formation and dynamics of large-scale coherent flow structures (CFS) over asymmetric tidal dunes are explored through the instantaneous velocity fields provided by the PIV measurements. Definite large-scale CFS similar to that over high-angle dunes are observed to form and evolve over the intermediate-angle tidal dune when the flow is aligned with the dune symmetry and the lee side is steep. However, weak CFS are observed over the low-angle tidal dune. Under reverse flow conditions, when the flow is opposed to the dune symmetry and the lee sides are gentle, large-scale CFS generation are significantly weakened due to attenuated shear layer development. The observed large-scale CFS characteristics highlight the significant influence of lee side morphology and flow bidirectionality on macroturbulent formation.
Scale effects arise in physical models when all the relevant forces are not perfectly maintained between different geometrically scaled models. The scale series diagnosis (different scales of laboratory dunes in this study) reveals that the main source of scale effects between the experiments is likely to come from the differences in the dune surface roughnesses and, hence, the near-bed flow regime. This mismatch is manifested as differences in the flow and turbulence properties leading to discrepancies in the measured flow properties over dunes. A careful assessment of potential scale effects in experimental models is, therefore, necessary before translating laboratory findings to full field scale conditions.
The complementary numerical experiments using a non-hydrostatic RANS-based model with k-ε turbulence model demonstrate the applicability of the model to predict mean flow and turbulence properties over tidal dunes under reversing currents at both experimental and full field scale conditions. The model reproduces the overall patterns of time-averaged streamwise flow field as well as the turbulent kinetic energy field, an indication of the model capability to capture the primary influence of tidal dune morphology and flow bidirectionality on flow dynamics.
This thesis provides new insights on the characteristics of flow dynamics over tidal dunes through detailed descriptions of flow and turbulence properties provided by multi-scale experimental and numerical modelling approaches. The presence and extent of intermittent and permanent flow separation over tidal dunes, documented for the first time at such a scale, has implications for flow patterns, hydraulic roughness and turbulence generation over tidal dunes. The presence and dynamics of instantaneous, unsteady large-scale CFS observed in this study has far-reaching impact on turbulent mixing and suspended sediment transport over natural tidal dunes. Overall, this thesis provides a first-order hydrodynamic (flow and turbulence) descriptions that can be used as a starting point for further studies involving flow resistance, sediment transport and morphodynamic evolution over natural tidal dunes under reversing tidal flows.
Subjects
Bedforms
;
Flow
;
Turbulence
;
Flume experiments
;
Numerical simulations
Institution
Researchdata link
Type
Dissertation
Language
English
File(s)![Thumbnail Image]()
Loading...
Name
Flow Dynamics above Tidal Bedforms_Kevin Bobiles_Dissertation.pdf
Size
11.04 MB
Format
Adobe PDF
Checksum
(MD5):5701d8d38014841bbc93afb87b7d5139
